Skip to main content

Ranking Inaccuracies Explained

Learn why personal Google searches may differ from Keyword.com, how Google ranking works behind the scenes, and how to properly verify your results.

Updated this week

What it is

Sometimes you may see:

  • One ranking inside Keyword.com

  • A different ranking when searching manually in Google

In most cases, this is not a tracking error. It’s the result of how Google serves search results.

This article explains:

  • Why ranking differences happen

  • How Google’s infrastructure affects results

  • How to properly verify rankings

  • When to escalate to support


Why ranking differences happen

Google does not serve one universal result. Rankings vary based on multiple factors.

1. Google data centers

Google stores search data across multiple global data centers.

When:

  • Keyword.com performs a scan

  • You perform a manual search

Each may connect to a different data center.

Because data centers do not synchronize instantly, temporary differences can occur. This is normal and usually stabilizes within days.


2. Personalized search results

Google personalizes results based on:

  • Your search history

  • Your Google account activity

  • Previous clicks

  • Previous device usage

If you’re logged into Google, your results are influenced by your profile.

Always verify rankings in:

  • Incognito / private mode

  • Logged out of Google


3. Location & IP address

Google adjusts rankings based on:

  • Country

  • Region

  • City

  • ZIP/postal code

  • IP address

If you are tracking:

  • google.co.uk (with no location)

But manually searching from:

  • Brighton, UK

You may see different results.

Your manual search must match:

  • The same Google domain

  • The same country

  • The same location setting

If exact location matching is not possible, use Spyglass to replicate the correct search environment.

For local tracking, see Google Maps & Local Pack Rankings.


4. Device differences

Desktop and mobile SERPs differ.

If you are tracking:

  • Google Desktop

But manually checking:

  • On a mobile device

You will likely see different rankings.


5. Google “Did you mean” and query rewriting

Google sometimes rewrites or corrects search queries when it believes a user has made a typo or entered an uncommon variation.

You may see messages such as:

  • “Did you mean…”

  • “Search for instead”

  • “Are you looking for…”

Depending on the region and language, this behaviour can appear in different formats.

Why this affects rankings

When Google shows a “Did you mean” suggestion, it may:

  • Show results for the exact term entered

  • Show results for the corrected term

  • Blend results from both

The final decision is made by Google’s algorithm.

If Google interprets your keyword differently from the exact text you are tracking, rankings may appear inconsistent when compared to manual checks.

For example:

  • You track a keyword with a spelling variation

  • Google decides the corrected term is more relevant

  • The SERP reflects the corrected query instead of the literal one

This can result in:

  • Different URLs ranking

  • Unexpected ranking shifts

  • Confusion when manually checking the keyword

What to expect in Keyword.com

Keyword.com tracks the keyword exactly as entered.

If Google rewrites or corrects the query during retrieval:

  • The ranking shown reflects the SERP returned by Google at the time of tracking

  • Manual searches may show slightly different behaviour depending on how Google presents the suggestion

This is a Google-level behaviour and not a tracking error.


5. Time differences

Rankings change constantly.

If:

  • Our scan happened hours ago

  • You manually search now

The ranking may have moved.

Use an on-demand refresh to force an immediate update before comparing.


6. Duplicate keyword searches in different projects

If the same keyword is added in multiple projects, we run a unique search for each entry.

This can result in:

  • Project A showing #8

  • Project B showing #9

This happens because each scan is independent and may connect to different data centers. This is expected behavior.


How to properly verify a ranking

Step 1: Refresh the keyword

Trigger an on-demand refresh to pull the most up-to-date data.


Step 2: Use Spyglass (ranking verification tool)

Click the Spyglass icon next to the keyword.

Spyglass shows:

  • A saved snapshot of the exact SERP at scan time

  • The ranking position we recorded

  • The Top 100 results (where applicable)

  • The region and location used

This is your source of truth.


Step 3: Match all settings exactly

When doing a manual search, ensure:

  • You are in incognito mode

  • Logged out of Google

  • Using the same region (country + location)

  • Using the same device type

  • Tracking method (broad domain or exact page)

  • Using the same Google domain (google.com, google.co.uk, etc.)

If location matching is difficult, use a web proxy matching the correct IP, or use Spyglass to simulate the exact search.


Understanding “Out of Tracked Range” (OTR) vs >100

Sometimes you may see:

  • OTR (Out of Tracked Range)

  • Or “>100

These are not inaccuracies.

OTR means:

  • The keyword was scraped

  • But not found within your tracked depth (e.g., outside Top 20)

>100 means:

  • The keyword was not found in the Top 100 at all

These depend on:

  • Your Hybrid Tracking model

  • Your Maintain Continuous Rank setting

They are expected outcomes based on scan depth.


Still seeing differences?

After:

  • Refreshing the keyword

  • Checking Spyglass

  • Matching device and location

  • Verifying incognito search

If the difference still exists, it is almost always due to:

  • Data center synchronization delay

  • SERP volatility

  • Real-time ranking movement

This is normal and usually stabilizes quickly.


Frequently asked questions

Why don’t you track beyond Top 100?

Anything beyond Top 100 is effectively considered unranked in practical SEO terms.

Tracking deeper provides little strategic value and significantly increases resource cost.

Why do rankings sometimes “bounce”?

This is often caused by:

  • Data center synchronization

  • Minor algorithm adjustments

  • Temporary SERP testing

Short-term fluctuations are normal.


Best practices

  • Always verify using Spyglass first

  • Use on-demand refresh before comparing

  • Avoid checking rankings while logged into Google

  • Match exact tracking settings (region, device, location)

  • Don’t compare desktop tracking with mobile searches

Did this answer your question?